How to Spot a Fake Insurance Certificate | FIRST, VERIFY

August 10, 2021

Collecting and making sure that Certificates of Insurance (COIs) are accurate and up-to-date is an enormous task, especially when you do not have tools to streamline this process. On top of this, checking to make sure you are not receiving fake insurance certificates is difficult.


Here are a few best practices to follow when checking the authenticity of a COI.


1. Look for “Acord 25”


The most common insurance certificate used by trustworthy insurance agencies is Acord 25.


A real Acord form will have the Acord logo in the upper right-hand corner and the text “Acord 25” in the bottom left-hand corner.


If the words “Acord 25” cannot be found in these places on the form, that is a red flag that this is not a legitimate insurance certificate.


2. Look for Consistent Handwriting & Font


Looking at the expiration dates on insurance certificates you receive is a good place to check for fraud. If the dates are not in the center of the box or if they are in a different font than the policy number, there is a good chance the COI is a fake.

Keep a lookout for anything handwritten or in a font that does not match the rest of your form. This is a good indicator of a fake insurance certificate.


3. Call the Insurance Company & Make Sure They are Legitimate


If you have a bad feeling about a COI, you receive, call the insurance company that issued it. If the company does not answer or if the agent you get in contact with does not want to talk to you or seems hesitant, this is a red flag.


If you do not recognize the insurance company listed in the upper right of the certificate, call your insurance agent to make sure they are a legitimate company.

AMBest.com is also a good place to check the status of an insurance company. Use their “ratings and analysis” section to look up the insurance company in question and see if they are legitimate. 


4. Understand the Layout


The layout of COIs is complex, and somebody creating a fake likely will not know how to fill out the form.


Look for these sections in Acord 25 forms:


  • General liability
  • Worker’s compensation
  • Automobile liability


These are common types of coverage you can expect to see on most forms.

If you see coverage like Cyber Liability, make sure this coverage is part of the insurance policy. If there is coverage listed in the COI that you cannot find in the insurance policy, the COI is probably a fake.


It is also important to look out for things like zeroes, N/A, or None listed when there is coverage not included in the policy that is present on the COI.

On an actual proof of insurance certificate, these boxes will be left blank to state the limit. 


5. Make Sure the Insured Box is Filled Out Correctly


The name in the insured box on an insurance certificate should be the name of the business, not a person’s name. The business address should also be in the box.

It is important to check this section when looking for a fake COI because if an inexperienced person filled out the form, they will probably put their name in this section.


Another important reason to check this box is to make sure coverage is afforded in the case of a real insurance certificate. If the name in the box is not correct, coverage may not apply when a claim is made.


6. Look for the Right Contact Information


The contact information on an insurance certificate should be the information of the insurance agent or broker who issued the form. If this information is instead for the person who is covered by the certificate, they probably filled out the form on their own.

The signature at the bottom of the certificate should also match the name in the contact information box. Lastly, the email domain in the contact information should match the name of the Producer of the certificate, that is the name of the insurance company. 


If any of this information seems off, do a quick search online to make sure the person who created the COI works for the Producer or call them to confirm. 


If you are unsure of how to identify a fake COI and keep track of your contractor’s insurance policies, check out FIRST, VERIFY’s COI Management web application. Find out how we can help you reduce the risk associated with fake policies and increase compliance at all times.

You might also like

Multi-Site Contractor Verification for Safety Programs
March 10, 2026
Learn how consistent contractor verification across locations strengthens multi-site safety programs and improves contractor compliance oversight.
By Erica Montefusco March 4, 2026
EDITOR'S NOTE: Our friend Erica Montefusco , Senior VP, Risk & Compliance at PROtect, wrote the following post on LinkedIn. We liked it so much we asked if we could republish it as a guest blog. This is the first of four com-panion pieces on resilience and leadership, which will appear in future guest blogs. _______________ There is a misconception that industrial risk leadership is rigid. Regulations. Standards. Checklists. Audits. Metrics. On the surface, it can look procedural. But the longer I’ve worked in risk, safety, and compliance, the more I’ve realized something unexpected: This career is not about rigidity. It’s about exploration. Curiosity Is a Risk Control Before I worked in industrial environments, I was fascinated by anthropology, archaeology, and scientific dis-covery. Why civilizations rise. Why they collapse. How systems evolve. How small environmental or cultural shifts compound over time. That lens never left me. In industrial risk, the same principles apply. Organizations don’t experience catastrophic failure without signals. Drift occurs gradually. Norms shift quietly. Pressure normalizes shortcuts. If you’re not curious, you miss it. Curiosity is not abstract in this profession. It’s protective. Asking: Why is this procedure written this way? Why are near-miss reports declining? Why does this site feel different than others? Why did supervision behavior change under schedule pressure? Risk leadership requires scientific thinking - observation, hypothesis, pattern recognition. It is less about enforcement. More about investigation. Cultural Understanding Shapes Safety Culture Traveling the world, experiencing different countries, belief systems, and social norms, it reshaped how I view organizational culture. Every culture, whether national or corporate, has invisible rules. What is spoken openly. What is avoided. Who challenges authority. Who doesn’t. Safety culture operates the same way. You cannot implement risk controls without understanding cultural dynamics. If speaking up is culturally discouraged, Stop Work Authority will fail. If production pressure is celebrated as heroism, incidents will rise. If environmental stewardship is treated as compliance instead of responsibility, corners will eventually be cut. Leadership requires cultural literacy. And cultural literacy begins with humility. Exploration Builds Resilience Exploration, whether physical or intellectual, builds resilience. When you’ve navigated unfamiliar terrain, when you’ve faced environments outside your comfort zone, when you’ve experienced adversity and uncertainty… you learn something essential: Calm is a choice. In industrial risk leadership, calm is not optional. Emergencies happen. Incidents occur. Regulators ask hard questions. Executives look to you for clarity. Your tone becomes the baseline for everyone else. Resilience is not bravado. It’s steadiness under pressure. That steadiness is built long before crisis arrives. It is built through challenge. Scientific Curiosity and Regulatory Discipline Risk work is often viewed as regulatory. But at its core, it is scientific. Observe. Measure. Analyze. Adjust. Environmental compliance demands precision. Safety programs demand behavioral understanding. Risk mitigation demands systems thinking. The most effective leaders in this space are not just rule-followers. They are investigators. They want to understand: What is really happening? What patterns are emerging? What assumptions are we making? Where is drift occurring? Exploration and science share a common foundation: Intellectual honesty. If something isn’t working, you change it. If evidence contradicts belief, you adapt. That mindset has shaped how I lead. The Connection Between Stewardship and Leadership The longer I work in this field, the more I see risk leadership as stewardship. We are entrusted with: People’s safety. Community trust. Environmental integrity. Corporate reputation. Financial stability. That is not a small responsibility. Travel has taught me how interconnected systems are. Environmental work reinforces that daily. Air doesn’t stop at property lines. Water doesn’t respect ownership boundaries. Reputation doesn’t isolate itself to a single event. Leadership requires long-term thinking. Exploration teaches you to look beyond the immediate horizon. Why This Matters Now We are entering a period of increased transparency. AI-driven analytics. Real-time environmental monitoring. Data visibility at unprecedented levels. The future risk leader must be more than compliant. They must be: Curious. Culturally aware. Scientifically grounded. Emotionally steady. Ethically anchored. Industrial leadership and exploration are not opposites. They are parallel disciplines. Both require courage. Both require humility. Both require adaptability. Both require respect for forces larger than yourself. And both demand resilience. Closing Reflection If there is one thing my professional career and personal philosophy share, it is this: Never accept the surface. Look deeper. Ask harder questions. Challenge assumptions. Stay steady under pressure. Protect what matters. Risk leadership, like exploration, is not about control. It is about understanding. And understanding is what ultimately keeps people safe.
Centralized Contractor Data
March 4, 2026
Learn how centralized contractor data, automated COI tracking, and structured contractor prequalification reduce administrative burden while strengthening safety...

Book a Service Today